• Question: why dont we disect frogs in the uk and only in america WHY

    Asked by bath1smew on 31 May 2024.
    • Photo: Neil Barnby

      Neil Barnby answered on 31 May 2024:


      When I was at school, we dissected rats, but this has many issues, as does dissecting frogs or other animals. Firstly it is wrong to kill animals just to use them as an educational tool, especially when there are so many alternatives. These animal have a right to live and to use them in schools to illustrate their physiology is not humane. In modern times there are many alternatives including using models and virtual reality as tools to do the same thing. Another issue is that it causes stress in many pupils who have to perform the dissection. I remember so many of my school friends being upset by the whole process. In the UK for these and other reasons (basically cost) we decided to stop the process.
      In America it is also becoming less common, partly because of the animal rights groups and partly the cost. You cannot just dissect any animal you have found, they have to be from a specialist company that checks for diseases etc.
      Although your questions initial specified frogs, even in America they rarely dissect frogs, except in the movies, they mostly use fetal pigs and worms, as I understand it.

    • Photo: Caroline Roche

      Caroline Roche answered on 6 Jun 2024:


      Ease of access and current school trends/curriculum. It’s alot easier to get a heart or kidney of an animal from the butchers than trying to find a frog suitable for dissection. Also depending on the school it might be easier to study anatomy from a book or computer than in a biology lab.

    • Photo: Kirsty Ross

      Kirsty Ross answered on 7 Jun 2024:


      Mostly because we do not need to. As Neil says, there are other ways of exploring anatomy without cutting into actual animals. And as Caroline says, using materials from butchers shops is a way of using the whole of the animal and wasting nothing. It is a very personal choice whether an individual chooses to take part in such activities and so it shouldn’t be forced. Personally, I have done dissections at university and found it absolutely fascinating and crucial to my education.

Comments